Do I Know You?

Dire Passages powered by GURPS

First Adventure, The Case of the Missing Merchant, Session 013

This is an emergent narrative; this story is the retrospective recounting of a TTRPG Session that involved emergent play in an open world.

Opening Narration

There is no question in the English language more innocent in its appearance, nor more troublesome in its consequences, than the simple inquiry, “Do I know you?” It is ordinarily accompanied by a polite inclination of the head, a narrowing of the eyes, and that agreeable expression a gentleman adopts when he is attempting to place a face without admitting that his memory has gone to pieces. In respectable company the question generally produces a name, a handshake, and perhaps an invitation to dine. In less respectable circumstances it may produce a denial, a sudden departure, or the discovery that the gentleman asking the question has considerably more in mind than renewing an acquaintance.

Now, New Orleans is a city where being known has always been something of a profession. A Creole family may spend three generations establishing a reputation which one foolish grandson can destroy in an evening. A merchant may be known for his honesty, though his creditors would be astonished to hear it. A politician may possess such an extensive acquaintance that he can scarcely walk a block without encountering someone to whom he owes a favor, a promise, or an explanation. And there are gentlemen whose entire livelihood depends upon being familiar to the right people while remaining complete strangers to everybody else.

The late war has made this business of recognition especially delicate. A man may find himself shaking hands with someone who once commanded the guns that fired upon his regiment. He may encounter an old acquaintance wearing a uniform of an entirely different color, or discover that a former hero has become a clerk, a confidence man, or a respectable officer of some newly established commercial concern. The years have dealt unevenly with reputations. Some men have exchanged their swords for walking sticks, others their principles for appointments, and a considerable number have discovered that the safest way to explain their activities during the rebellion is not to explain them at all.

There is also the curious matter of a gentleman’s name. We are taught from childhood that a man’s name is his most valuable possession, though anyone who has examined a hotel register, a gambling-house ledger, or the records of a police magistrate will discover that names are remarkably easy to manufacture. A fellow may enter one establishment as a respectable businessman, leave another as a sporting gentleman, and spend the remainder of the evening being sought by persons who know him under an altogether different designation. The trouble with assuming a new name is that the old one does not necessarily consent to be buried. It has a disagreeable habit of following its former owner about, sometimes with a creditor attached.

Yet I have observed that familiarity is an even less reliable guide to character than a name. A mother may know the exact hour her daughter ought to retire, the proper arrangement of her hair, and the precise manner in which she should conduct herself at supper, while remaining profoundly ignorant of the burdens she carries. A father may examine the shape of a skull, pronounce upon the condition of the nerves, and confidently prescribe a remedy without having discovered what the patient is suffering from. Such things are not always evidence of a want of affection. They merely demonstrate that love, like science, is occasionally afflicted with an excessive confidence in its own instruments.

The professional investigator is supposed to rise above these deficiencies. He is expected to distinguish honest men from rogues, identify an acquaintance from across a crowded room, and detect deception in the briefest exchange of courtesies. This is an admirable ambition, but it places rather a great deal of trust in the human eye. A face may be familiar without being friendly. A stranger may offer a warning in the guise of a greeting. And the mere fact that one gentleman recognizes another does not establish which of them has the advantage. Indeed, I have known men who would have cheerfully surrendered a month’s wages for the privilege of remaining unrecognized for another five minutes.

There is a peculiar cruelty in this business. We spend our lives wishing to be remembered. We cultivate acquaintances, preserve letters, commission portraits, and take elaborate precautions against being forgotten. Then, when remembrance finally arrives, we discover that it has come from a most inconvenient quarter. The wrong man remembers our face. The wrong woman remembers our name. Some obscure transaction, which we had confidently consigned to history, is suddenly recalled in the most disagreeable detail. And a perfectly ordinary question, uttered with impeccable manners, becomes something altogether different.

It is Monday evening, the fifth of February, eighteen hundred and sixty-six. The Crescent City’s lamps are being lit, the respectable households are preparing for supper, and the less respectable establishments are beginning to conduct their evening business. Across the city, people are seeking explanations from strangers, assurances from acquaintances, and comfort from those who ought to know them best. They will discover, as so many have before them, that recognizing a face is a small accomplishment compared with understanding the person behind it.

And as for that innocent question—”Do I know you?”—a prudent gentleman might consider very carefully before answering.

Approximately 8:30 PM, Monday, February 5, 1866 – A Cold House (Madeleine, Leopold)

Victorian-era woman wrapped in a floral shawl holding a rolled document beside a man in a dark coat and top hat in a candlelit hallway

The dinner bell had sounded at the Mercier Villa, and the household was preparing to observe the proper hour with its customary insistence upon proper appearances. Somewhere below, dishes touched a sideboard and a servant went quickly along a corridor. Upstairs, Leopold Schuyler had just entrusted a message to a servant for Augustin Labat. An appointment had been requested; an answer would have to await the morning. There was nothing more to be done about the prospective appraisal that night.

When he turned from the errand, Madeleine stood in the passageway. She wore the same dress in which he had seen her earlier, but it was disordered, and a comforter from her bed was pulled about her shoulders. The color had gone from her face. Her eyes were bloodshot, and her customary poise seemed to have been left somewhere between the restaurant and this hallway.

“Why is everything so cold?” she asked.

Leopold did not immediately meet her eyes. He made a small business of adjusting his cuffs, glancing toward the stairs, and considering the domestic inconvenience of a woman wrapped in bedding when the dinner bell had already rung. It was easier to speak of a cup of tea than of what had happened to her hands around Tinny Boudreaux’s ring.

“Maddie, could I interest you in something warm? A cup of tea, perhaps?”

“It is so cold for this time of year,” Madeleine replied. Her voice was her own again; that alone distinguished the woman in the corridor from the strangely childlike figure he had brought home.

“Certainly. But tell me—do you remember anything of the journey?”

“I do not remember coming back.”

Leopold considered that answer with less composure than he showed. “You were in something of a fugue. Do you remember anything at all?”

“I did a drawing when I first woke up.”

“A drawing? Well, you needn’t fetch it this instant. Why not eat something first and get your humors into a more reasonable condition?”

Madeleine, however, was prepared to retrieve what she had drawn. She went to her room and returned with the tube containing her papers. Leopold watched her movements closely enough to recognize a new and disturbing fact: the young woman might be speaking normally, but she did not look remotely well. He had seen her frightened, had seen her exhausted by her gift, and had seen her carry on after experiences that would have left many people incapable of polite conversation. Tonight her face had an ashen quality that even the poor light of the passage could not conceal.

“The tea first,” he said, with a gentleness that sounded a little overcareful. “Then supper, if you can manage it.”

It was a reasonable prescription, and therefore a comforting one. Whether it addressed anything actually wrong with her remained another matter.

Monday Evening – A Different Sort of Search (Lars, Caleb)

Victorian-era horse-drawn tram crowded with passengers on a rain-soaked, gaslit city street.

At No. 18 Carondelet Street, Lars Prittwitz and Caleb Grayson had arranged a more practical remedy for the frustrations of the day: they would go back into the streets and ask questions of people who had known Adrien-Luc de Saint-Cyran when the missing gentleman ceased to behave like a gentleman.

Two women remained unaccounted for in their enquiries. Their names were Marguerite and Sadie. Caleb knew roughly where they had worked and had enough of a description to attempt a search, but the banks of the Carondelet Canal and the neighboring working districts were no single address. The search promised many doors and very few people eager to answer a stranger’s questions.

“I’ll begin with the two women,” Caleb said. “Go from place to place until somebody knows the names. There can’t be many places they frequent.”

Lars had a different task in mind. “You do the asking. I’ll follow at a distance and see who is interested in the man doing the asking.”

“A block or two?”

“About that. Close enough to know where you have gone, far enough that we don’t look like companions.”

“You know where I’m going,” Caleb observed. “Unless I suddenly have to run for something, you ought to be able to find me.”

The arrangement suited both. Caleb was the more obvious figure, broad and formidable, and his knowledge of the sporting life gave him a plausible reason to enter places where a gentleman from an insurance office might be received with considerably less confidence. Lars, dressed down in workingman’s clothes and an unremarkable cap, could watch the watcher without pretending to enjoy a dozen rounds of cheap whiskey.

They took advantage of the evening streetcar while it still ran. By nine o’clock such easy transport would cease; the return journey, whatever its hour, was likely to be made on foot. Beyond the respectable trade of the American Sector, the streets grew less obliging. The brickwork gave way in places to weathered timber, dark yards, small drinking houses, and premises that had no particular interest in supplying a passerby with their names. The canal carried the smell of everything the district did not care to keep.

At the first stopping place, Lars allowed the big man to go ahead. He had no intention of playing the friend, assistant, or bodyguard. That was precisely the sort of association he was trying to conceal.

The Same Evening – The Dinner Bell (Madeleine, Leopold, Dr. Alphonse Mercier, Contessa Bianca)

Victorian-era dinner scene with an elderly man arranging a seated woman’s hair while guests dine at a candlelit table.

In the Villa kitchen, Leopold discovered that hospitality was more complicated than boiling water. He had first looked about for bourbon, an ordinary restorative after an extraordinary afternoon, and had instead found the household’s cooking sherry. The chef regarded his appearance among the pots with the guarded patience reserved for a gentleman likely to interfere with dinner.

“Mr. Schuyler, may I help you?”

“I’m perfectly capable of preparing tea, thank you,” Leopold said, though he started when addressed. “Miss Mercier has had something of a chill. I thought a warm cup might assist her.”

The chef offered a stronger drink. Leopold declined any need for assistance, fortified himself modestly from the available sherry, and managed the kettle. When a maid asked whether Madeleine would be late to table, he explained that the young lady was unwell, but was nevertheless making her way downstairs. He wished the servant to convey no more alarming intelligence than that.

At dinner, the household’s composure failed almost as soon as Madeleine appeared. Dr. Alphonse Mercier occupied one end of the table, as befitted the master of an establishment he could barely afford to maintain. At the other sat Contessa Bianca Mercier-di Valenza, whose education had not prepared her to greet an adult daughter in disheveled silk and a bed comforter as though she had merely chosen an unconventional shawl. A servant halted with the next course. Glass and silver made a small, irregular chorus of surprised clinks.

“Madeleine,” her mother said, “what is wrong with you, my dear?”

“It’s terribly cold, Mother. How are you not bundled up? I’m freezing.”

“The fire is properly stoked. The house is quite comfortable. Is this how you mean to dress for dinner?”

“I’m terribly sorry. I did not expect to wake to such a frightening chill.”

“You have a chill?” Bianca repeated. “Then you are ill. Alphonse, your daughter is sick. What do you intend to do about it?”

Dr. Mercier set down his wine with the air of a man whose services had been formally demanded by an entire continent. He rose, went around the table, and approached Madeleine’s chair with the dramatic gravity of a celebrated physician summoned to a delicate case.

“My dear, let us see. Sit still a moment.”

“Papa, I am only cold. Everything else is quite all right. Do sit and have your dinner.”

He was not so easily deterred. With his smallest fingers he felt delicately along her neck, then moved to her skull, testing its contours as though the evidence of her distress might have lodged in a particular prominence of the bone. A man in another profession might have confined himself to asking whether she had eaten. Alphonse was possessed of professional methods and therefore had to employ them.

“Hmm. Indeed. There is increased pressure here. Perhaps a disturbance in the cranial functions.” He changed his angle, frowned, and tried another part of her head. “Have you suffered a shock today?”

“Not that I recall.”

“Not that you recall? What precisely do you mean by recall?”

“I went about the usual business of the day. I appear not to remember coming home.”

At the table Leopold concentrated on his supper. His knife moved through the meat with a deliberation that did not require him to enter the conversation. He had brought her home himself, but the account of the ring was a subject to which he looked forward with considerably less enthusiasm than the soup.

“Tell me how you came to be in this state,” Alphonse pressed. “Who was with you?”

“Leopold was with me. And his associate, Mr. Tinny. I was inspecting a ring. I had a frightening vision, Papa, but as you know, these things happen. The next thing I remember is waking upstairs.”

Alphonse turned. “Mr. Schuyler. Explain the circumstances of this meeting.”

“Certainly. My associate Boudreaux possesses an antiquarian ring which may be of interest to the Labat family. We were discussing its prospective valuation. Miss Mercier provided one of her customary readings—an interpretation which, if it offered some historical interest, might naturally assist us in establishing the article’s worth.”

“A customary reading,” the physician repeated.

“Quite. She was tired afterward, as one might expect. I saw her safely home and encouraged her to rest.”

Madeleine had no memory with which to contradict the details of that journey. She knew the vision had been frightening; she knew that something was missing between the restaurant and her bed. Those two certainties were more troubling than any pronouncement about the shape of her skull.

“Had you anything to drink, my dear?” Alphonse asked.

“Why, no. You know I drink only for medicinal purposes.”

“Tell me more of this ring,” he said, then checked himself. The maid had paused again. “Maria, continue serving. Madeleine, eat. When you are finished we shall have a private conference upstairs. That will include you, Mr. Schuyler.”

The doctor drew the comforter back about his daughter’s shoulders. The meal proceeded, but it had ceased to be an ordinary family dinner.

Monday Night – The Iron Hook (Caleb, Lars)

The Iron Hook lived up to its name without the bother of embellishment. It was a hard drinking house in a hard quarter, crowded with sailors, hands from the yards, small-stakes gamblers, and men who regarded questions as a form of insolence unless the questioner was purchasing the next round. There was enough tobacco smoke to hide a conversation and not nearly enough warmth to make anybody pleasant.

Caleb entered alone. Lars found a place from which he could see the room without making an exhibition of himself. If somebody took an interest in Caleb’s movements, the Pinkerton intended to discover it before that interest became a dangerous proposition.

The former cavalryman approached the work with cheerful persistence. He bought modest drinks, let the patrons speak of their troubles, and tried to move from the ordinary lamentations of working life toward the two women he wished to find. To avoid dulling himself with liquor he nursed his own glass with remarkable restraint. Unfortunately, a man may succeed in staying sober at the expense of appearing to be the only sober man in the company.

“Evening, gentlemen,” Caleb ventured. “Care for something to wet your throats?”

He was met with the rough courtesy accorded a stranger who brought money. That courtesy lasted only so long as the drinks. Caleb did not know these men, and they did not know him. As he tried to turn the discussion toward Marguerite and Sadie, the questions seemed less the casual enquiries of a sporting fellow and more the business of a man gathering information without giving any in return.

The bartender set both hands against the wooden bar, then moved one beneath it. He was not as large as Caleb, but his establishment supplied him with other advantages.

“You,” he said, loud enough to quiet the nearest conversation, “are bad for business. I think I’d like you to leave.”

Caleb considered the invitation. There was little sense in manufacturing an argument simply because the first approach had failed.

“Very well,” he said. “Plenty of other bars.”

He went out with no useful name or address. A few men looked after him, and the room resumed its conversations as soon as it was safe to do so. Lars followed in his own time. The better part of an hour had been purchased with drink money, and the only certain discovery was that the Iron Hook had no appetite for an inquisitive stranger.

Neither man had yet seen convincing evidence that anyone was following them. The dark streets offered no guarantee that a watcher was absent, merely that he was not visible.

Later Monday Night – The Mussel Man (Caleb, Lars)

Rainy historic canal street at night with a man in a cap watching a distant pedestrian beneath glowing streetlamps

A few blocks farther on stood an establishment whose name invited confusion from anyone who did not know its trade. The Mussel Man referred not to the measurement of a prizefighter’s arm but to the shellfish which figured in its business. Compared with the Iron Hook, it possessed a certain modest respectability. Irish accents carried over the tables, and the clientele appeared mostly to be neighborhood men who had regular occupations to return to in the morning.

This time Caleb managed his entrance better. He drank sparingly but did not look as though he feared the contents of his glass. He listened, bought drinks, and introduced himself as a man from another part of the city. A patron studied him with the familiarity of one who had seen a very large fellow compete in the ring.

“Haven’t seen you here before,” the man said. “Where do you hail from?”

“Other end of town,” Caleb replied. “Always a pleasure to find a friendly place.”

“My friend Mingus says he knows you. Mingus!”

A fellow approached at the summons, looked Caleb over, and became cheerful with recognition.

“Oh, I’ve seen you fight. Mighty right cross you carry, big fellow. Though I don’t know whether you’d be a match for Jack McGee.”

“Jack McGee? Is he a wrestler?”

“A boxer. A coming man. Some sporting fellow you are not to know the name.”

“I do a little boxing,” Caleb allowed. “Mostly grappling. Different rules.”

That distinction did not discourage the man’s commercial imagination. His cousin, it emerged, had a hand in Jack McGee’s management. A prospective opponent had fallen out of a coming bout. Could Caleb, if the terms were suitable, be prevailed upon to take his place? The champion might even be present, or so the man had heard. It was precisely the sort of interesting prospect by which one might earn a payday and acquire bruises in the same transaction.

“We could use a fall man for McGee,” the fellow suggested. “A strong fellow such as yourself would look well opposite him.”

“I should want to hear what was being offered before agreeing to anything,” Caleb replied.

“Certainly. Your name?”

“Caleb.”

The fellow produced paper and asked where a message might reach him. Caleb gave an address, which was duly written down. There was talk of advertising him under the Cossack persona by which he was sometimes known in the ring.

“Don’t go printing that yet,” Caleb said. “Let me hear the arrangement first. If it suits, we can discuss the rest.”

“Fair enough. I’ll speak to my cousin in the morning.”

The conversation was of no immediate advantage to the search for Adrien-Luc, but it had the cheerful merit of being genuine local sporting gossip. It had also drawn a listener whose attention did not seem altogether devoted to pugilism.

From his unassuming seat Lars observed a gentleman far better dressed than the tavern required. He had handsome, closely composed features and the easy elegance of a man accustomed to entering rooms where he was not questioned. A trace of silver touched his dark hair. He seemed not to be listening in the vulgar manner of an eavesdropper; he simply allowed no movement, no name, no address in Caleb’s conversation to escape him.

Lars studied him, then recognized the face. This was the man at the café by the City Hotel, the one Caleb had noticed while the investigators were watching the scarred Frenchman’s movements on Sunday. Here he was again, in a different quarter, listening while strangers made a record of Caleb’s name and whereabouts. The discovery did not reveal the gentleman’s employer, but it disposed of any belief that the second appearance was an ordinary coincidence.

Caleb eventually returned to his principal object. “Perhaps you can help me in another matter. I’m looking for a woman called Marguerite. She sometimes works near the canal.”

“Oh, I know the sort of place she keeps,” the man replied. “She’s tried her trade in here once or twice, though she’d find this house a little above her customary company. Look along the canal, or try a place called the Den. Several blocks farther up, on the left.”

“The Den,” Caleb repeated.

“Mind yourself if you find her,” the man added, lowering his voice. “She may be contagious, if you follow me.”

Caleb accepted the warning for what it was: an unverified opinion offered with the cheerful confidence of neighborhood gossip. He thanked the men and left. Twenty seconds or so later the handsome gentleman rose and walked out after him.

Lars did not immediately follow. He gave the stranger time to move, observed the direction taken, and then set off himself. He had found what he had come to look for: a watcher with a familiar face, attending closely to Caleb’s affairs.

After Dinner – A Physician and His Daughter (Madeleine, Leopold, Dr. Alphonse Mercier)

Two men in period clothing converse in a dimly lit library, with one holding a decorative cane.

Back at the Villa, Dr. Mercier had not forgotten the conference he had promised. When the meal was finished, he arranged to hear his daughter’s account in a quieter room and asked Leopold to remain available. Whatever the night had done to Madeleine, her father intended to discover what part of it could be described in medical language and what part might have to be assigned to the folly of other men.

“My dear,” he said, “begin at the beginning. You touched the ring?”

“Yes, Papa. I touched it and had a vision. A very frightening vision. After that I cannot tell you how I came home.”

“An interruption of memory. And before this, you had no such difficulty?”

“Nothing that I remember.”

“Hmm. Nervous exhaustion,” he said, with the satisfaction of a man who has found a phrase sufficiently learned to occupy a difficult space. “One must be cautious when the nerves are exposed to repeated shock. There may be fits of delusion as well. We shall have to protect you from further excitement.”

Madeleine had heard physicians explain her gift before. She knew enough to distinguish a diagnosis from an answer, though she did not quarrel with him. She wished only to be warm and to have the missing hours made comprehensible.

Alphonse produced laudanum and offered a small medicinal spoonful. “Just a taste of this, now that you have eaten. Then into bed, and no more exertion tonight.”

“Yes, Papa.”

She would rather have kept the medicine than swallowed it. When her father’s intentions proved more immediate than that, she took the spoonful, and later tried to spit it out. The precaution did not prevent its effects. Before long the night’s exhaustion and what she had swallowed drew her into a heavy sleep.

Leopold found himself summoned to a separate conversation. Alphonse followed him into his room, closed the door, and raised his silver-topped cane before him—not as a weapon actually used, but as a most expressive instrument of paternal disapproval.

“What,” the physician asked, “have you gotten my daughter into?”

“Nothing beyond the ordinary course of our work, Doctor. It was a routine reading. She was somewhat tired afterward, and I thought rest would be beneficial.”

“Routine? Mr. Schuyler, if I have not made myself clear, she is subject to nervous exhaustion and occasional fits of delusion. Her predilections are valuable to this household—indeed, valuable to you in your work—but you must not subject her to such drama.”

“I understand.”

“Do you? Because I had understood that these services were to be managed with some discretion. Yet now I hear of an antiquarian ring, a gentleman named Boudreaux, and an appraisal of which nobody has thought to inform me.”

Leopold explained that the ring remained in Tinny’s possession, that a respectable buyer had expressed interest, and that he had only just sent word to the Labat family seeking an appointment. There was also the possibility of the forthcoming ball; the exact timing of any examination had not been settled.

Alphonse listened. His anger became more orderly as the details began to resemble a profitable social engagement.

“Very good,” he said at last. “There shall be two rules moving forward, Mr. Schuyler. The first is the immediate one. I shall accompany you to this appraisal. Keep me informed the instant an appointment is made.”

“Certainly.”

“And I shall expect recompense for the services of my daughter. You will arrange that with your associate. If it must come out of your own percentage”—he smiled without much warmth—“then out of your own percentage it must come.”

Leopold bowed his head in acknowledgment.

“The second rule is of greater duration. No more independent readings without first informing me. I should dislike having to speak to certain mutual friends concerning certain names.”

The remark required no explanation to achieve its effect. Leopold made no demand to hear which names the physician had in mind.

“Crystal clear, Doctor,” he said. “I shall not make the same mistake twice.”

Alphonse withdrew his cane, satisfied for the present. Leopold had not escaped a warning merely because the patient was asleep. If anything, the quiet of the house made the warning easier to hear.

Later Monday Night – The Den That Was Not (Caleb, Lars)

A fisherman in a hat sits beside a lantern-lit canal at night, viewed through an open doorway.

Beyond the Mussel Man, Caleb’s route led farther along the canal. The tavern noises diminished behind him, and even the municipal lamps seemed disinclined to follow the road. The water lay black between rough banks. At intervals a bridge crossed the channel, but these were practical crossings built for tradesmen and carts, not ornaments of a fashionable promenade. Timber yards and closed shops offered dark walls with few windows bright enough to reassure a man of his company.

Caleb became conscious of footsteps behind him. In a busier street they might have meant nothing. Here, in the thinning traffic, they were harder to dismiss. He kept walking toward a light that might mark the establishment described to him.

Outside it, a sailor well advanced in drink was making his departure with the unsteady determination of a man whose immediate goal was to remain upright.

“Is this the Den?” Caleb asked.

“Was the Den,” the sailor replied, pleased to be consulted. “Until Mackle bought it. Sinking Skiff now.”

“The Sinking Skiff.”

“Drinks are fine,” the man offered. “And that is a splendid mustache you’ve got.”

He reached toward the bristling ornament, as though hoping to test the workmanship, and then wandered off before the liberty could develop into an argument.

A short distance away Lars had noticed a second man. He wore a stained blue coat and stood close to the canal. He was singing to himself, softly and repeatedly, the same simple refrain about a woman coming around a mountain. The singer was not making a spectacle of his amusement. He seemed content to sit by the dark water and throw the occasional pebble into it while his little tune came around once more.

“She’ll be coming ’round the mountain when she comes,” the fellow murmured.

Lars stopped where he could observe the man without appearing to do so. A cheerful singer in a desolate street was not a crime, but the repeated refrain struck him as potentially purposeful. He watched for a response from across the canal or farther along the bank. None came that he could establish. The man simply continued to sing and occasionally send small stones into the foul water.

At length Lars left the singer to his pleasures and entered the tavern. He could see the well-dressed gentleman farther inside, positioned to keep Caleb in view. Lars chose a seat from which to observe him in turn. The man did not look in his direction, and for the moment that was all the advantage the Pinkerton needed.

Monday Night – The Price of a Drink (Caleb, Marguerite; Lars nearby)

Crowded 19th-century New Orleans tavern with patrons drinking and dancing, while a worried woman sits alone at a table beside an oil lamp.

The Sinking Skiff was busier than its exterior promised. Workingmen laughed over mugs; somebody was singing an old drinking song with great sincerity and imperfect memory. A woman with dark hair danced with a patron who seemed pleased with a recent bonus and more pleased with the company upon which he intended to spend it. The place was neither respectable nor quite the worst of the river district. It was a house in which a woman might work and perhaps, if the proprietor permitted it, find some protection from what waited outside.

Near one table sat a slim woman with tired, dishwater-blond hair. She was dressed for her trade, her face carefully painted, though the eyes behind the paint did not share the cheerful invitation of her clothes. She seemed to watch the doors almost as faithfully as she watched the room for customers.

Caleb approached. “May I sit?”

“Are you going to buy me a drink?” she asked.

He glanced at the glass before her. “I might. Though it seems you haven’t finished that one.”

She called to the bartender, who brought another and announced the price: three dollars. Caleb looked at the man as though the glass ought to contain a small portion of the establishment’s ownership.

“Three dollars?”

“Three,” the bartender repeated.

Caleb paid. The woman studied her unexpected patron and gave him the terms of a transaction she evidently considered ordinary.

“For the price of a drink, monsieur, all you get is a gamahuche.”

“What’s that mean?” Caleb asked.

“It’s a French trick. What you Americans call getting your prick sucked.”

“I see,” he said, perfectly unflustered. “Well, I’m looking for information, not an evening.”

“Information.” She held the word a little longer than she had held the drink. “And what sort of information?”

“I’m looking for a gentleman. French. Well dressed once, I’d say, but in very poor condition when he was last seen. Something of a gambler. He may have owed money to a friend of mine.”

Her gaze shifted toward the door. “You might tell me a little more than that.”

“A thin fellow. Not well at all. Had been taking substances, from what I hear. He was with a man called Balthazar Tremblay, and two women. I thought one of them might be you.”

For a moment she studied the big stranger’s face. His manner was matter-of-fact, more the approach of a man settling a business question than one threatening a woman who had very little protection. He had not tried to purchase her body as a pretext for demanding an account of her friends. That distinction was apparently worth something.

“Speak quietly,” she said. “You mean Adrien-Luc.”

Caleb gave a small acknowledgment. “So you knew him.”

“Knew him? He was crazy.”

The words came out with a sharpness that drew a glance from a nearby table. She lowered her voice further.

“He wanted vile things, monsieur. And by vile I don’t mean merely what a priest disapproves of in a young man on a Saturday night. There were things said about drawings and prayers. He took us into places we had never been. And the powder—God preserve us, the amount of cocaine he took! It was far too much.”

“You were with him on the last night he was seen?”

“I was.”

“And what became of him?”

She looked directly at Caleb. “He’s dead, monsieur.”

“How do you know that?”

“Because I saw him die.”

Outside, the canal continued to move under its burden of refuse. The statement might have been made in a courtroom for the certainty with which she delivered it, but there was no court here and no witness beyond this exhausted woman who had survived whatever she claimed to have seen.

The Same Night – What Marguerite Saw (Caleb, Marguerite; Lars)

Moonlit historic waterfront village with a wooden bridge, lanterns, rustic buildings, and reflections on the canal at night

Caleb did not make a sudden movement. He had come prepared for gossip, perhaps a name or an address. He had not expected to be told, across an expensive drink, that the missing merchant was dead and that the person speaking had watched it happen.

“Was it that same night?” he asked.

“Yes. Balthazar had been with us. Then he left us. Adrien-Luc was in a terrible condition, out of his mind with the powder and everything else. He said he would dive from the bridge.”

“He said that?”

“He went off it,” she insisted. “Into the canal. And he never came up.”

“Which bridge?”

She gave him the location as she understood it, a crossing far enough along the canal to place the event near the upper reaches of the district they had been searching. Caleb could picture the sort of bridge she meant. The existence of such a place proved nothing about how a man had entered the water, but it was a location a careful investigator might actually find again.

“Did anybody go after him?”

“Do you suppose I could have pulled a man like that out of the canal? Or that I wanted the police questioning me about what he had been doing all night?”

She had not come to the Skiff in search of an official hearing. Caleb gave her room to continue. Her account of the man’s final hours remained tangled in drink, drugs, odd religious language, and fear. She was quite certain that he had gone into the water deliberately; she had offered no independent proof of what happened below its surface.

“And Tremblay?” Caleb asked. “Where is he now?”

“Balthazar knows bad people. That’s why I’ve stayed here. Mackle lets me work in the house for half what I might earn outside, but at least I can shut the door at night. I live upstairs. I never leave.”

“Never?”

“I haven’t slept right since that night. Every time I go out, there are people. And things. I see them in the shadows. Perhaps it’s his ghost.”

“Whose ghost?”

“Adrien-Luc’s, you fool. Who else?”

Caleb was in no hurry to quarrel with the explanation. The woman was afraid; that much was apparent whether the cause was a ghost, a living enemy, or the cumulative punishment of a life lived among dangerous men.

“Do you think Balthazar has something the Frenchman wanted?” he asked.

She caught at his coat with sudden urgency. “He took a case. Adrien-Luc had a case with him, and Balthazar took it. I saw that. Whatever has gone wrong, it has something to do with that case. He has something that belongs to the dead man.”

“A valise?”

“A case. Call it what you like. You must find Balthazar, monsieur. Please. And if you find him, tell me what you learn.”

“Where might he be?”

“Nobody’s seen him for more than a month. He used to be everywhere. Now he’s nowhere.”

“What about Sadie?”

“I saw her once after all this. She used to work by the river, though I saw her nearer here that time. I don’t know where she is now.”

The woman was no less distressed for having supplied names and a lead. Her eyes repeatedly traveled toward the door. Caleb knew enough about the company he kept and the people who sometimes watched him to recognize the possibility that his visit might prove dangerous to her in its own right.

He put another five dollars down for the information. She accepted it without any sudden return to merriment.

“Tell me if you find him,” she repeated. “Promise me you’ll let me know when it’s safe.”

“I’ll bear that in mind,” Caleb said. “And you take care of yourself.”

She looked him over once more. Some remnant of professional humor survived the fear.

“So,” she asked, “do you still want your prick sucked? You’ve paid the price.”

“No, thank you,” Caleb answered. “A day at the office will do me.”

He left her with the untouched promise of a trade she had offered and the more expensive information he had actually come to purchase. Behind him she finished her drink and sat staring down into the glass.

Across the room Lars had kept his attention on the elegant gentleman, who seemed to be devoting his own to Caleb. The conversation itself had been too distant and the room too loud for Lars to hear. He knew only that it had engaged the watcher and that Caleb’s departure would require care.

Later Monday Night – A Signal on the Street (Lars, Caleb)

As Caleb approached the doorway, he saw the man Lars had been observing. The recognition came late, but it was enough to confirm that the elegant watcher had followed them from the previous establishment. Lars was positioned nearer the exit. Caleb made a small adjustment to his necktie, conspicuous only to a companion expecting a signal. They needed to speak.

Lars rose and went out a little more abruptly than Caleb had anticipated. The big man was still putting his tie right when he realized the Pinkerton had already left. Caleb followed him into the night. Beyond the building, beside the canal, the man in the blue coat was still singing softly to himself, as though he had been provided by the night to furnish it with a soundtrack.

The two investigators had very little time together. Caleb brought Lars up to the principal points of his conversation.

“She says Adrien-Luc is dead. Claims she saw him go off a bridge into the canal. There’s a case he was carrying, and Tremblay took it.”

“That is something,” Lars said.

“More than something. She’s frightened out of her wits. And if that man saw me talking to her, I worry he may have given her a death sentence.”

Lars cast a look toward the tavern. “Then we had better not stand here making the connection any plainer.”

“Agreed.”

“Go on home. I’ll watch the fellow.”

Caleb began walking. His revolver was kept within reach. The well-dressed gentleman emerged from the tavern and moved toward the street, but before following Caleb he passed very close to Lars. He stopped. His face, handsome and composed, turned directly upon the apparent workingman.

“Excuse me, monsieur,” he said, rather more loudly than the circumstances required. “Do I know you?”

Lars kept his manner easy. “I don’t believe so, sir.”

“Ah. I thought for a moment I recognized you, but I was entirely mistaken. I wish you a very good evening.”

“And you as well.”

The gentleman continued in Caleb’s direction. Lars had been studied at close range; he knew that much, and knew that the man’s voice had carried farther than a private apology demanded. He removed his cap to change his outline, let the stranger put several blocks between them, and then resumed the pursuit with a care born of necessity.

The canal lay to one side, dark and odoriferous. Behind the closed fronts of the working quarter there were alleys by which a man could cut across a block without passing beneath a lamp. Lars kept the handsome figure in mind and judged the distance ahead, trying to regain the advantage he had lost when the stranger stopped to speak.

Then came a scrape from immediately behind him.

The Street Fight – Two Shots in the Dark (Lars, Caleb)

Lars turned enough to see the fellow from the canal. The stained blue coat had followed him. The singer’s good humor was gone; in its place stood a short, wiry man with sandy hair and a baton in his hand. He was already striking.

There was no time for an argument or for the elaborate warnings by which two gentlemen occasionally pretended a quarrel was still preventable. Lars caught the blow on his guard and parried it aside. The baton passed without finding his head or shoulder. He was off balance for an instant, but not helpless.

His hand dropped to his pistol. The weapon came free with the practiced speed of a man who had spent years preparing for moments he hoped would seldom occur. Lars brought it to bear on the attacker, setting his aim while the other fellow shifted forward and tried to strike the gun hand itself.

The blow came close. Lars stepped back and slipped clear of it. The baton did not knock the revolver from his grasp.

At a distance of scarcely two yards, the affair ceased to resemble an athletic contest. Lars fired.

The report cracked between the buildings, sharp and enormous in the empty street. The bullet struck the man in the chest. He recoiled and went down upon the paving, the blue coat collapsing around him. Lars did not stop to take a pulse, inquire into the wound, or establish whether the fellow might rise again. The man had attacked him from behind, had been shot, and was on the ground. That was all Lars could know for certain as the echoes of the pistol discharged into the night.

Farther along the street Caleb heard the shot and turned toward it. His own revolver came out as he started back. The handsome follower was in view—and had drawn a pistol of his own. About fifteen yards separated the two men.

For an instant both were ready to fire, but the other man was quicker. His weapon flashed. Caleb did not remain standing erect to discover whether the shot would find him. He threw himself down and away from its line, escaping the ball. The movement put him upon the street, very much alive and exceedingly aware of the difference between an empty-handed argument and a loaded pistol.

The well-dressed shooter did not advance to finish the business. He turned into a side alley and ran, disappearing from Caleb’s view.

Lars was already moving toward his companion. He had heard the second shot, and at that distance he could not know whether Caleb had been struck. He came upon the big man beginning to rise from the ground.

“You hit?” Lars demanded.

“No. I’m sound.”

From the Sinking Skiff came voices, then the rough movement of chairs and feet as patrons rushed outside. A shot at night drew an audience quickly; two shots invited everybody to believe the trouble had begun in earnest.

“What was that?” somebody shouted.

“Somebody’s been shot!”

“There—up ahead! Must be those two!”

It was time to leave. The investigators did not pause to explain the matter to the neighborhood. Lars moved toward an alley and urged Caleb away from the bright doorway and the swelling crowd.

“We ought to split,” he said. “They’re looking for two men together.”

Caleb agreed. They took different passages through the dark, each avoiding the people who had come to investigate the gunfire. Neither was caught; neither saw his pursuers establish a definite identification. The armed gentleman had vanished, and the injured baton man had been left behind. There was no streetcar now to shorten the journey to Carondelet Street.

The walk home was long enough for both to appreciate how little distance had separated an investigation from a funeral.

Elsewhere That Night – The Second Drawing (Leopold, Madeleine)

Man reading an illustrated antique book by candlelight in a dark bedroom, with a sleeping woman in the background.

At the Villa, Madeleine slept with the unnatural depth of somebody whose exhaustion had been given chemical assistance. Her attempt to avoid the laudanum had not saved her from its effects. The house had fallen quiet around her. Whatever dreadful chill had greeted her on waking appeared, for the present, to have yielded to oblivion.

Leopold went to her room. He had come to see the drawing again. He took care to close the door and moved with the discretion of a man who did not wish to attract the attention of Dr. Mercier or anyone else in the house. The tube was near the bedside, where Madeleine had left it.

The first drawing, the crude picture made during her strange childish state at the restaurant, appeared as he disturbed the papers. Its huge simple lines had the proportions of a young child’s attempt to draw a frightening creature. Leopold had seen that one already. What concerned him now was the later image, made after Madeleine awoke and could employ her ordinary artistic skill.

He unrolled it and stood very still.

The creature was neither an ordinary jaguar nor merely a man wearing an animal’s skin. The body was massively developed and almost human in the arrangement of its muscles, but its fingers ran into long talons. The head belonged to a great cat, dark as polished coal, with lighter markings barely showing against the black. Its fangs were visible, and blood ran from them. In the whole construction there was an awful suggestion of life, as though the artist had not invented a monster but attempted to record the anatomy of something she had actually seen.

Leopold recognized details that answered, though not reassuringly, to the Mesoamerican designs he had spent so many hours examining. The artist’s knowledge had apparently supplied no comforting boundary between antiquarian symbolism and the sight before him.

He did not wish to continue looking at the face. It was not simply ugly, and not merely an image of violence. The figure seemed to be looking down at whoever held the paper. The blood was real enough in the drawing to make the viewer conscious of the fangs long after he had lowered his eyes.

He rolled the lesser image away and considered what her father might make of the greater one. Mercier had already spoken of delusions and nervous exhaustion; a picture of such a creature could hardly improve the consultation. Leopold decided to hide it.

Madeleine’s shelves held a mixture of devotional works, classical authors, and the literature suitable to a cultivated woman. Leopold chose a substantial volume of Shakespeare’s *The Tempest*. He folded the detailed drawing carefully and concealed it among the pages at the beginning of Act II, then returned the book to its place. The child’s picture and the remaining papers were left with the tube.

Madeleine slept through it. She knew nothing of the removal of her drawing, and Leopold did not wake her to explain what he had done. He withdrew, closing the door behind him as quietly as he had entered.

Late Monday Night – The Price of Recognition (Lars, Caleb)

By the time the two men reached No. 18 Carondelet Street, the waterfront encounter had lost none of its sharpness. They had traveled separately and reassembled without being overtaken by the people who came running from the tavern. The office offered walls, a door that could be secured, and the opportunity to speak about the night without a stranger close enough to hear their words.

Lars began with the danger he believed Caleb had faced.

“Those men were after you, I think. They have been following us often enough. Whether they meant to kill you tonight, I cannot say, but I may have spoiled their arrangement.”

Caleb was not satisfied by such certainty. “It may have been the conversation with the woman. If they saw me speaking to her, perhaps that changed the situation. I don’t know what they intended.”

“They made me,” Lars said. “The handsome one looked me over and knew I was following. Then the fellow with the sap came up behind me.”

He went back over the movements aloud, treating the encounter as he would a report: who left first, who waited, what was said, where each man stood. The more carefully he reconstructed the sequence, the more a particular exchange acquired weight. The well-dressed man’s rather theatrical enquiry—*Do I know you?*—had been spoken with excessive volume. It had occurred exactly when Lars ceased to be an anonymous figure in the background.

“That was not an innocent question,” Lars concluded. “It was a signal.”

“A signal to the man in the blue coat?”

“Yes. That is why he spoke so loudly. The singer was waiting to be told whom to strike. Once they recognized that I was watching their principal man, the baton fellow went to work on me.”

It was a sharper conclusion than the one they had entertained upon escaping. Whatever larger purpose the watchers had in mind, they had coordinated the attack against Lars after discovering his counter-surveillance. The exact purpose of the assault—whether to kill him, incapacitate him, or simply punish his interference—remained uncertain. The practical fact was beyond argument: someone had tried to bring a baton down on him from behind.

“And you shot him,” Caleb said.

“I did. Hit him in the chest. He fell. I don’t know what became of him afterward.”

“You had rather little alternative.”

“He had a sap. Perhaps something else besides. I wasn’t going to wait while he made up his mind what to do with it.”

Neither man could say where the elegant watcher had gone or whether he might recognize Lars again. The encounter had provided the investigators with a face seen at close range, but not an address, name, or employer. It was information of one kind and ignorance of several others.

They returned to Marguerite. Caleb supplied the details of what she had said inside the Sinking Skiff: the wild conduct of Adrien-Luc, the powders, the canal bridge, the missing case, and Silks Tremblay’s disappearance.

“She insists she saw him die,” Caleb said. “He went off one of those canal bridges, so she says, and never came up. It may be true. She was there.”

“Or she may be telling the part that suits her best,” Lars replied. “People are apt to arrange stories so they come out looking better in the light.”

“True enough. Still, there’s a bridge we can look for. And she says Tremblay took a case belonging to the Frenchman. That seems the stronger lead.”

“And she says she’s haunted.”

“She does. It was distressing to hear. She may be frightened by men who really are following her, or she may have taken too much of the same things the Frenchman took. I cannot tell.”

“The doctor might make something of it,” Lars said. “Or perhaps not. I wish we had him here to ask.”

Caleb allowed that the woman was visibly unwell and might have mistaken fear for a ghost. Neither investigator was willing to pronounce the supernatural explanation proven, but neither could dismiss the terror in which she lived. After the gunfight, the possibility that living men might be responsible for that terror had become considerably less abstract.

“Balthazar Tremblay, then,” Lars said at last. “That’s where the case went, if her account is right. We need to find him.”

“Silks,” Caleb supplied. “That’s the name they use.”

“I recommend you stay here tonight,” Lars said. “I don’t propose to give that gentleman another clear shot at you on the road home.”

Caleb agreed to remain. They would rest, then meet their companions in the morning and compare what each had discovered. There was no further pursuit of Silks that night, nor another attempt to revisit the canal. They had learned enough to recognize the danger of pressing their luck without a plan.

Outside, the city continued its business in darkness, entirely indifferent to how nearly two investigators had become its next casualties.

Early Tuesday Morning, February 6, 1866 – A Note Beneath the Door (Madeleine, Leopold)

The morning came to the Mercier Villa without settling any of the questions the preceding evening had raised. Madeleine woke somewhat improved in body. The fierce sensation of cold had eased, but she remained uneasy, as though the memory of the ring had left some small alarm sounding where an ordinary night’s sleep could not quite silence it. She would have to dress, leave her room, and resume the obligations of the day. No explanation of the black jaguar had come to her in the night.

Leopold rose in his own room. A folded note had been slipped beneath his door. He took it up and read the answer to the message dispatched before the previous night’s dinner bell.

Augustin Labat would be pleased to receive him at the family estate on Tuesday, February 6, at any time between one and two o’clock in the afternoon.

The reply was an invitation to call and discuss the matter, not an appraisal already performed and certainly not a sale. Tinny Boudreaux still possessed the ring. The prospective price remained subject to the independent examination the buyer required; even now the object had not entered Labat’s hands.

Leopold read the note again. Dr. Mercier had insisted upon accompanying him and receiving compensation for Madeleine’s participation. Tinny must be informed of the time, for a seller could not exhibit a ring he had not brought. There were practical messages to send and a morning routine to get through before anyone could present himself at the Labat Estate.

He intended to notify the necessary parties. He had not yet set out. Whether his companions would accompany him, and what might come of the appointment, belonged to the day ahead.

In another part of the city Lars and Caleb would have their own account of the night to deliver. For the moment the two groups had not yet assembled to exchange their discoveries. The investigators were left with a letter offering a respectable afternoon meeting, a frightened witness pointing toward a vanished pimp, and the unwelcome certainty that someone had used a pistol in the street to discourage further questions.

It was Tuesday morning in New Orleans. Nothing had been resolved merely because the sun had returned.

Leave a Reply